Reeths-Puffer placed second at Friday's O-K Green Conference tournament on its home mat, though the Rockets still earned the overall league championship.
The Rockets scored 158.5 points to place behind only Byron Center, which they beat in the regular season.
Four R-P wrestlers earned individual titles: Sage Secrest (215 pounds), Max Knowlton (106), Travis Henderson (113) and Ian Cook (144).
Secrest pinned both of his opponents, and Cook and Knowlton each had a pin and a technical fall in the tournament. Henderson won both his matches by major decision.
Devin Welch (285), Cory Judd (126) and Hunter Eek (157) were runners-up in the conference.